Breaking the Pain Cycle: Hope Beyond the Hurt
- Simon MacLachlan

- 4 days ago
- 6 min read

An Overview of Chronic Pain
You injured yourself months or years ago, but your pain is persistent, remaining long after your tissues, injury or illness have healed. Small things appear to set your symptoms off. Your pain seems to increase if your mood or stress worsens. You're completely fed up, doctors don't seem to help because they can't understand or diagnose the problem, or perhaps you've been told "it's in your head". Is this you? If you can relate to any of this, you may be living with chronic pain.
How does chronic pain develop, and how can we treat it? What determines who experiences chronic pain and who doesn’t?
This article will answer some of these questions, explore effective ways to better manage and treat chronic pain, and suggests that chronic pain can often be well-treated with psychological interventions, even if the initial injury or condition was physical in origin.
Chronic pain is pain that persists beyond the normal time expected for healing, typically longer than 3 months, and is maintained by ongoing changes in the nervous system, when tissue damage has healed or is no longer the primary cause. It is not in your head. It is real, and is influenced by the brain and nervous system, which can become increasingly sensitised over time – particularly when focused on and worried about (Stretanski, 2025).
Chronic pain is separate and distinct from acute pain associated with tissue damage or injury. Chronic pain occurs when an acute injury, such as a bursitis of the shoulder or temporomandibular joint dysfunction associated with jaw clenching, effectively heals, but the pain associated with the original injury remains, despite complete resolution of the injury itself.
Chronic pain can be debilitating, and is associated with mental health difficulties including anxiety, depression, trauma, stress, insomnia and emotional overwhelm. Secondary effects of the pain or symptoms often give rise to or worsen existing stress, anxiety, hypervigilance, rumination, insomnia, and functional impairment leading to work-related burnout, disablement or other serious downstream consequences. This is the vicious cycle of chronic pain.
Those with chronic pain often meet the criteria for ACEs (adverse childhood experiences), have experienced significant trauma, or already have a history of depression or anxiety (Schubiner & Betzold, 2022).

How Psychological Processes Can Perpetuate Chronic Pain
Pain is not simply a signal sent from injured tissues to the brain. Rather, it is an experience created by the brain based on information from the body, the nervous system, and our past experiences. When pain persists, the nervous system can become increasingly sensitive, causing it to produce pain even when tissues have healed or are no longer significantly damaged (Abass & Schubiner, 2018).
Several psychological processes can unintentionally keep this cycle going:
Hypervigilance
When pain is persistent, it is natural to become highly aware of bodily sensations. Constantly monitoring for signs of pain can increase the brain's perception of threat, making pain signals more noticeable and intense.
Fear and Avoidance
Many people begin avoiding activities they believe might worsen their pain. While this is understandable, prolonged avoidance can lead to reduced strength, confidence, and movement, reinforcing the brain's expectation that these activities are dangerous.
Catastrophic Thinking
Thoughts such as "I'll never get better," "Something must be seriously wrong," or "This pain is ruining my life" increase emotional distress and activate the body's stress response. This heightened state of threat can amplify pain sensitivity.
Stress and Emotional Distress
Stress, anxiety, depression, unresolved trauma, and emotional overload can increase nervous system arousal. When the brain perceives danger—whether physical or emotional—it may become more likely to generate pain as a protective response.
Reduced Activity and Deconditioning
Persistent pain often leads people to move less, withdraw from valued activities, and become physically deconditioned. This can reduce the body's resilience and reinforce the belief that movement is unsafe.
Learned Pain Patterns
After months or years of persistent pain, the brain can become highly efficient at producing pain in response to certain movements, environments, emotions, or situations. These patterns are learned through repetition, much like any other habit, and can be modified through psychological and behavioural treatment. This is often referred to as neuroplastic pain, or central sensitisation.

Hope Beyond the Hurt
Despite some of the negative consequences of living in persistent pain, there is hope. The same capacity of the nervous system to learn pain also means it can learn safety. Psychological treatment does not suggest that pain is "imagined" or "all in your head." Rather, it helps reduce unnecessary danger signals within the nervous system by changing patterns of attention, beliefs, emotions, behaviours, and physiological arousal.
As the brain becomes more confident that the body is safe, the nervous system often becomes less protective, allowing pain to gradually reduce and function to improve.
Research has found that three people can have the same back injury with identical tissue damage or disc degeneration, but have three completely different experiences of pain. One individual may notice mild pain that quickly resolves; another may notice no pain at all, and yet another may have chronic, long term pain lasting years, with debilitating consequences, functional and occupational impairment, loss of confidence, lost income, and many other psychosocial implications.
Factors associated with prolonged pain can involve how we perceive pain and injury as threatening. Therefore psychological treatment can often be one of the most crucial aspects of healing chronic pain (Schubiner, Howard & Betzold, 2022).
How Psychological Therapy Can Help Chronic Pain
Modern psychological treatments for chronic pain recognise that persistent pain is often maintained by an overprotective nervous system rather than ongoing tissue damage alone. Although each therapy approaches this in a different way, they all aim to reduce fear, increase a sense of safety, and help the brain and nervous system become less sensitive over time.

Internal Family Systems (IFS)
Internal Family Systems (IFS) helps people understand the different "parts" of themselves that develop in response to pain and adversity. For example, one part may constantly monitor the body for danger, another may fear movement or injury, while another may feel hopeless or overwhelmed.
Rather than trying to suppress these parts, IFS helps individuals relate to them with curiosity, compassion, and understanding. As protective parts begin to feel safer and less burdened, the nervous system often becomes less vigilant and less likely to interpret bodily sensations as threatening, reducing pain intensity and improving quality of life (Schwartz, Siegel & Schubiner, 2021).
Pain Reprocessing Therapy (PRT)
Pain Reprocessing Therapy is based on the understanding that many cases of chronic pain are maintained by a sensitised nervous system rather than ongoing structural damage.
PRT helps people reinterpret pain as a sign of an overprotective nervous system rather than evidence of injury. Through education, mindful attention to symptoms, and gradual exposure to feared sensations and activities, the brain learns that the body is safe. As fear decreases and safety learning increases, pain often becomes less frequent and less intense (Ashar et al., 2022).
Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy (EAET)
Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy recognises that unresolved emotional conflicts, trauma, chronic stress, and inhibited emotions can contribute to persistent activation of the nervous system.
EAET helps individuals identify, experience, and express emotions that may have been avoided or suppressed. Processing these emotions in a safe therapeutic environment can reduce chronic stress responses, increase emotional flexibility, and lessen the nervous system's need to remain in a protective state, allowing pain to diminish over time (Lumley & Schubiner, 2019).
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT)
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy helps people change their relationship with pain rather than constantly struggling against it.
Instead of becoming trapped in cycles of avoidance, frustration, or hopelessness, ACT develops psychological flexibility—the ability to make room for difficult thoughts, feelings, and physical sensations while continuing to engage in meaningful activities and relationships.
As fear and avoidance decrease, many people find they become more active, more confident, and less dominated by pain. Although ACT does not aim to eliminate pain directly, reduced nervous system reactivity and increased engagement in valued living often lead to improvements in both pain and functioning.

An Integrative Approach
While each of these therapies has a unique emphasis, they share a common goal: helping the brain and nervous system learn that the body is safe.
Treatment may involve:
understanding how chronic pain develops,
reducing fear and hypervigilance,
processing unresolved emotional experiences,
developing self-compassion,
gradually returning to meaningful activities,
and building confidence in the body's capacity to move and heal.
As the nervous system becomes less protective, pain often becomes less intense, persistent and intrusive, allowing people to regain function, resilience, and quality of life.
Have hope: you can break the pain cycle and live a life of meaning and purpose. Contact Liminal Mind today to discuss how psychological therapy may improve your symptoms of chronic pain.
References:
Abbass, A., & Schubiner, H. (2018). Hidden from view: A clinician’s guide to psychophysiologic disorders. Psychophysiologic Disorders
Ashar YK, Gordon A, Schubiner H, et al. Effect of Pain Reprocessing Therapy vs Placebo and Usual Care for Patients With Chronic Back Pain: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Psychiatry. 2022;79(1):13–23. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2021.2669
Lumley MA, Schubiner H. Emotional Awareness and Expression Therapy for Chronic Pain: Rationale, Principles and Techniques, Evidence, and Critical Review. Curr Rheumatol Rep. 2019 May 23;21(7):30. doi: 10.1007/s11926-019-0829-6. PMID: 31123837; PMCID: PMC7309024.
Schwartz, Siegel & Schubiner, (2021). IFS and Chronic Pain: Parts that Hold the Hurt. Psychotherapy Networker: January/February Issue.
Schubiner, Howard, and Michael Betzold. Unlearn Your Pain: The Science of Recovering from Chronic Pain, Fatigue, Anxiety, and Depression. Mind Body Publishing, 2022. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
Schubiner, H., & Betzold, M. (2022). Unlearn your pain: The science of recovering from chronic pain, fatigue, anxiety, and depression. Mind Body
Stretanski MF, Kopitnik NL, Matha A, et al. Chronic Pain. [Updated 2025 Sep 28]. In: StatPearls [Internet]. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; 2026 Jan-. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK553030/


